“We are not Indian citizens, we are treated as slaves”

JK Bank


Mir Urfi


Mir Urfi

Tell us your journey to become a lawyer?

I joined the legal profession as an advocate in the year 2003 when I joined the Law Firm M/S Mir Shafkat Hussain and Associates after completing post-graduation in Law from University of Kashmir.

Prior to my joining the profession, I was ignorant about the socio-political scenario of Kashmir. I had a perception that situation in the Kashmir is absolutely normal and the people are living peacefully, but after I joined the bar, I realized that the people of Kashmir are the worst sufferers of the political subjugation and they are denied the basic human rights.

When I came across the victims of this scenario in Kashmir, I found that there is a vast difference between being a citizen of India and being a Kashmiri as far as his identity, his rights, and his relation with Union of India is concerned. As being part of this firm, I became more and more involved in dealing with these kinds of people and I my endeavour have been to provide legal help to them.

How do you see the current political situation of Kashmir?

I think the people of Kashmir are politically alienated. There are two political spectra, one is pro-Indian political group and another is the separatists’ camp. Even though they are called separatists but as I can see they represent the masses in Kashmir and can be said to be the de-facto representatives of the common people.

This is evident from the facts that in 2010 when entire Kashmir was on boil and the people were protesting on the roads. The All Party Delegation from the New Delhi came and met the separatist leadership to reach out to masses and try to calm the situation, despite of the fact that the Assembly of the state was intact and there were the so called representatives, the sitting MLAs [law makers], who were supposedly elected by the people.  Thus, the political situation in Kashmir is hit by worst turmoil as the people are not being represented by the genuine representatives.

And as far as gun culture is concerned, I personally feel that the armed struggle is less of the solution and more of the reaction. I think that when power becomes arrogant the violence becomes the order of the day. As long as the political subjugation is here, one cannot rule out the existence of the armed structure.  The armed struggle has been like an eruption of volcano where the silent sighs could not be held anymore and they started crying out to the world that they are suffering. I believe the armed struggle has been able to that extent to internationalize the Kashmir dispute and made New Delhi to think time and again that we need to enter into a dialogue with the Kashmiris to address the dispute.

Several young people have joined mainstream politics coming from different fields. Do you think any change because of that? 

Well, I think joining any shade of thought is one’s individual decision but what matters is how that individual then is taken in the society. If there are several young people joining the mainstream of India then there are even more who have joined the militant ranks and there were even greater number of youth, may be in lacs that had joined anti-India protests in 2008 and 2010, and even after that also whenever protests erupted.

And about the young people joining the mainstream, of which most of the young men have inherited the mainstream politics from their respective families, notwithstanding this fact, whoever joins the mainstream pleads before the people that he/she stands for solving the common problems of the people and not to sabotage their right to solution of the Kashmir problem.

What does the election process mean to you?

As long as Kashmir problem is not solved the election process is irrelevant and futile exercise which does not have the mandate of people. It is something which is not by the people, not of the people and resultantly not for the people. I don’t care for the elections. I believe it should not be given importance. It is like one party going rather one exploiter going and another coming.

Being a lawyer working in volatile Kashmir how do you see post –Afzal Guru hanging situation?

The hanging of Afzal Guru has once again reiterated the belief of the Kashmiri masses that Indian system is hostile towards them. It also showed how they have used their judiciary. Later on death penalty was converted to life imprisonment for many people who were supposed to be hanged before Afzal Guru like that of Rajiv Gandhi’s killers. This also proved that Kashmiris are treated as slaves and India is not interested in Kashmiri people but in land.

This thing should be accepted by India and by Kashmiris too that we are slaves and we are being denied by rights because some small part of Kashmiri people believe we are citizens of India and they should understand by such facts we are not Indian citizens at all and they never considered us as their citizens.

There are two sides of Kashmir’s politics, mainstream and separatists. How much you think they have been able to represent the people?

Separatists are the representatives who have not been selected by ballot. They represent the common sentiment of the people. They are relevant in the political spectrum because of the school of thought about Kashmir problem they carry on.  The mainstream politicians have always been maintaining that they stand for the administrative control of the State which is evident from their public addresses to the masses of Kashmir. Even the Chief Minister during his election campaigning has been pleading to the people that he stands to provide the basic necessities of life. On the other hand the representation of the separatists can be gauged from the response given to them during the uprising in 2008 and 2010 agitation. The mainstream politician are not elected by people but selected by New Delhi.

Can you say that youth of Kashmir have taken up politics now or is it too early?

I think there is no political spectrum in Kashmir so there is no question of youth joining the politics. Some people may be joining some political parties but they do not represent the political system. I think the handful of youth who have joined the politics have taken it more as a career than as statesman. The politics ensures them a bright future, being at the highest seat of administration and may be in certain cases not otherwise worth to it. The politics ensures them high standard living.

What do you think is the way forward for the solution of Kashmir issue?

Any political dispute is not so simple that one can have a solution which will fit straight away and Kashmir problem is no exception to that.  Every problem has a solution to it but the thing is that one should be ready to address it. The government of India should show its willingness to find a solution to the Kashmir problem as had been also promised by its first Prime Minister, Jawahar Lal Nehru, in UN Security Council.

The government of India should shun its rigidity towards the Kashmir problem, accept it as the dispute and then amicably work out a solution, taking all the stake holders on board. India should also show its willingness towards the solution by taking some meaningful steps like demilitarization, repeal of draconian laws amongst others so as to make the dialogue meaningful and result oriented.

Dear reader, we report people's voice...

Hence, we have not kept our content behind a paywall because we want their stories to reach everyone irrespective of reader's geographical location and economic status; but, you can help us remain independent by subscribing. The unbiased and free journalism needs resources and every contribution towards making mediascape a better place — however small or big — makes a difference. Subscribe today with as little as 39 rupees a month. Subscribe today »


  1. Ms. Urfi,

    First of all your demeanor reflects your secular credentials or lack thereof. I’d say France is the ideal state but in India we have ingrained pampering to religious bigotry at every level be it public or private and for all the religions be it Sikhism, Hinduism or Islam. Anyway, that doesn’t directly relates to body of your interview so I’d skip the rest of the bantering on this front. Only if ladies who wear hijab/burqa whether by force or voluntarily knew the history of wearing it.
    It’s rich for someone who belongs to a school of thought which disregards democratic ethos question the democratic setup of India. Centre has faltered once in 1980s if I recall well, to protect the democratic credentials in Kashmir and I agree that remains a sore blot on our otherwise peerless democracy. Before you jump to jingoistic criticism try to compare India’s democracy with the rest of the world, especially to any theocratic Muslim country (guess what, they don’t have it!).
    Between throwing stones and becoming a change-master through active political indulgence you know which is a better model, but then your Aakaas sitting across the border won’t pay their minions for the latter role. It is interesting how “Kashmir banega Pakistan” rhetoric is thrown under the rug after decades of economic growth in J&K and growing militancy/terrorism in Pakistan and Pakistan Occupied Kashmir. I laugh my socks off when I see how FATA and Baluchistan are counting bodybags in hourly rate and how military strongman drink martini sitting in Peshawar, Karachi and Lahore, especially Lahore.
    Sometimes I think let’s recall our soldiers from Kashmir and give them ‘autonomy’ (as if there isn’t already). Do you think that you’ll survive in the face of a radically charged Islamised Sunni Pakistan and an opportunistic China? Oh as you might be knowing your Muslim brethren in Xinjiang are finding knives as their veritable weapon against Chinese Sukhois, good luck to them!
    Your best interest is to be Indians. Choice is your to be a disgruntled, semi-literate, radical stone-pelter or become an active citizen in India’s growth story. Become CEOs, represent India in Chess, Cricket, Hockey, win Olympic Golds for Tiranga, become surgeons, civil servants (take cue from Shah Faesal), etc.
    Choice is to be a happy citizen of a progressive and emerging superpower or be an irritant bunch of idiots in a progressive and emerging superpower for Kashmir is part of India when men didn’t differentiate between goats and women in Arab lands (they still don’t).
    Good luck with your law practice, hope you make good use of it.

    • Now, i think you need to take cue from Shah Faisal…

      By the way, why are you worried about Kashmir’s future and how it will live between India, Pakistan and China, because you are not the Chacha Jaan pig entire world, right?
      Take care of yourself and let the Kashmiris decide their future and let them live the way they like…

      Kashmiris don’t need to be part of India to become doctors, engineers and lawyers etc. When they can become such personalities even during the current situation(where India is killing innocents everyday and all others are living in the threat of life), they can perform better if the situation in Kashmir is normal…

      Indian engineers themselves don’t have jobs and have to beg in other counties for jobs, sometimes work under foreign donkeys, what better will Kashmiris get…

      So, please don’t compare and don’t just throw something in the comments box without knowing the fact…

  2. Mohammed Ashraf you and some paki chu.. think themselves to be smarter but the world knows you and islamic terrorists in valley of kashmir are narrow minded relegious morons.First of all kashmir is for ages been india.Islamic invasions did dilute the population that too only in valley.Countries like England ,France also should note this developments in this part of our world seriously since soon this islamic morons will ask a seperate country in west midland in england and in parts of France.

  3. Ms Urfi
    The people like you should come out of the den ( i.e. burka ) and see the world scenario in relation to the political as well as religious set up. Obviously you will cherish the Indian democratic set up and yes being a lawyer, definitely you might have known the making process of The Sacred Constitution. Go and spend some days in another country like China only and the realisation will put you in brooding. …….so come back there from and express that all in black and white. Hope to listen the ‘view’ from you,…….my dear lawyer.

  4. Kashmir was always a part of India. It is not only Kashmir but whole of Pakistan, FATA, Afghanistan was in India. The mugals invaders changed the scene by forcing, raping the local Hindus to Islam. It is funny and also amusing to see that you are holding this fake identity as your original forgetting that your names are still Bhat, Kaul, Wani which are essentially Hindu names. Bloodshed takes place in Kashmir because your youth is being trained and encouraged by Pak. See what is happening in Fata and POK, there is no development. In Kashmir you have good roads, infrastructure, all facilities but still you prefer to stand in the way between terrorists and indian army. Nobody will tolerate terror backing and that too at our cost. When you cry for your so called rights, where was your conscious when Kashmiri Pandits were raped, murdered, looted and kicked out of Kashmir. If you think your conscious is still awake take up their cases and fight for them. Will you? Remove your black hijab, it narrows your view.

  5. Kashmir dispute is nothing but islamic terrorism being supporter by pakistan as pakistan called as terroristan is terrorist manufacturing industry of the world which breeds islamic terrorists and exports them all over the world to conduct terrorist attacks.Pakistan a failed state is notorious to finish its minorities which reduced from 30 percent in 1947 to 2 percent now in 2019.Religious bigots mullahs and jihadi terrorists have completely hijacked this country and minority is almost completely finished from this country.These Islamic morons dream not only to capture and convert India into Islamic state but whole world as evident from these jihadi morons.Islamic terrorism is biggest threat for humanity and civilized world as we have already seen in the case of ISIS and al qaeda,Boko haram,taliban and lashkar toyba,jaish mohammad,harkat ul ansar,gazwatul hind,indian mujahideen and all other islamic terrorist organisations which dream to kill every kafir of the world and convert whole world into islamic shariah state.Need of hour is to crush this islamic terrorism with full force and finish it otherwise it will destroy whole world.

  6. If you are treated as slaves in India, go to a country like Pakistan, where you will be treated as kings. Do not waste time here and disturb us. We would be better off without namk haraams like you. Jisaka khate ho, usi kee buraai karte ho.