Comments on: The ghost journalists of Kashmir

By: Kousar Mohiuddin

Kousar Mohiuddin — Mon, 16 Apr 2012 15:34:56 +0000

Those who say journalism preachers do not have the real experience of the feild have forget that a master never tries his skill in the field,instead he makes his pupil to do so. Now it depends on is the pupil really the worthy one,if not then he is a failure before his master and then he is bound to become a source to N A Ganaie.

By: jehangir

jehangir — Sun, 15 Apr 2012 19:53:47 +0000

Eh? The writer does make some good points, but in the end, he almost agrees to what Naseer Ganai says in his article. A good attempt though.

By: Riyaz

Riyaz — Sun, 15 Apr 2012 19:19:36 +0000

Yea right, How about this? Many budding journalists were bullied by the journalists like Naseer and his other colleagues in the same press colony. Will he talk about that? Those budding passionate journalism student were discouraged and always insulted by these “Pseudo-Pro-kashmir senior Journalists.”
In kashmir there are very limited opportunities and such budding reporters fled to some other govt- operated newspapers, where they were brought up in what appears to us as “pseudo-inteletual” and government- servant type environment. The concern mentioned in your writeup is genuine, but the fact i am stating here is a part of the story and must be added as well.

By: riyas

riyas — Sun, 15 Apr 2012 19:14:49 +0000

Yea right, How about this? Many budding journalists were bullied by the journalists like Naseer and his other colleagues in the same press colony. Will he talk about that? Those budding passionate journalism student were discouraged and always insulted by these interest “Pseudo-Pro-kashmir”"senior Journalists.”
As we know in kashmir there are very limited opportunities and such budding repeaters fled to some other govt-operated newspapers, where they were brought up in what appears to us “pseudo-inteletual” and government-servant type environment. Your concern mentioned in your writeup is genuine, but the fact i am stating here is a part of story and that must be added as well.